The Letter to CDU Members of 6 February 2024
A Personal Statement by Axel E. Fischer
On 6 February 2024, I addressed the members of the CDU in a detailed letter. In it, I explained my political work in the Council of Europe, the allegations made against me at the time, and why I firmly rejected them. What follows is a record of my perspective at that time.
Political Responsibility Also Means Taking Uncomfortable Positions
During my time as a member of the German Bundestag, I critically questioned political decisions—even when they were made by my own party or a CDU-led federal government. I was particularly critical of developments in energy and migration policy, as well as the handling of the coronavirus pandemic. As we can see today, RIGHTLY SO.
At the same time, I maintain that the sixteen years under Chancellor Angela Merkel were, taken as a whole, good and largely successful years for Germany. Justified and urgently necessary criticism of individual decisions must not obscure that overall achievement.
My Work in the Council of Europe: Dialogue Rather Than One-Sided Partisanship
A significant part of my foreign-policy work focused on the countries of Eastern Europe and the South Caucasus. As a long-serving co-rapporteur for Armenia and later for Ukraine, I maintained extensive contacts with political representatives from a wide range of countries, including Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia.
My aim was to bring these countries closer to Europe and to our shared values of democracy and the rule of law. I was always aware that Azerbaijan, like Armenia and Georgia, was no model of democracy or human rights. Shortcomings in elections, the rule of law and fundamental rights must be clearly identified.
But anyone seeking political change must, as I remain convinced to this day, maintain dialogue even with difficult counterparts. My principle was and remains: the same standards for all countries. Progress deserves recognition; setbacks must be criticized. Incidentally, this applies to Germany as well.
I never saw myself as a representative of either Azerbaijani or Armenian interests. I always made my political decisions according to my convictions and my conscience.
4 March 2021 – A Day My Family Will Never Forget
On 4 March 2021, my youngest daughter’s ninth birthday, our family home and my Bundestag offices were searched. The birthday candles had just been blown out when officers from the Federal Criminal Police Office arrived.
Such a search is not only a serious intrusion into private life. It also places a burden on the family. The searches were reported nationwide. For me, this marked the beginning of a period in which my character and my work were publicly judged, while for a long time I did not know in detail what exactly the allegations were based on.
The January 2024 Indictment – and My Response
It was not until January 2024 that I became aware of the indictment issued by the Munich Public Prosecutor General’s Office. On 22 January 2024, that office informed the public of the allegations. In my letter to CDU members, I expressly rejected the allegations because I know they are baseless. Even today, I am appalled at how easily state institutions can destroy the lives of law-abiding citizens.
Allegation of an Agreement to Engage in Political Activity in Exchange for Money
According to the indictment, I allegedly agreed in 2011 to act in Azerbaijan’s interests in the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe in exchange for payment. I expressly deny that any such agreement existed.
Allegation of Influencing Personnel Decisions
I was also accused of supporting the nomination of a member of the Monitoring Committee on behalf of another person involved. I rejected this allegation as well.
Allegation of Voting Allegedly Driven by Particular Interests
The indictment further claimed that I had acted in favor of Azerbaijan through speeches and votes. My votes reflected my political convictions. The fact that an individual decision may have benefited a particular country does not, in itself, establish improper influence.
As early as my statement of February 2024, I referred to passages in the investigation file indicating no conspicuous pro-Azerbaijani voting pattern.
Allegation of Payments
Finally, I was confronted with allegations of payments totaling 21,800 euros in 2016, as well as further payments from 2015 which, according to the prosecuting authorities, were time-barred. I denied having received any such payments.
When News Coverage Becomes Trial by Media
I was particularly critical of the public communications surrounding the January 2024 indictment. Even before a court had decided whether to open the main proceedings, the allegations were made public and taken up by the media.
At almost the same time, a three-part ARD documentary about the affair was announced. A parliamentary event to present the production was also planned. The timing raised questions for me. Who is funding all of this, and why—with what aim?
Freedom of the press is indispensable to our democracy. Equally indispensable, however, are the presumption of innocence, personal rights and fair proceedings under the rule of law. An indictment is not a conviction.
The Rule of Law Must Also Apply to Politically Controversial Figures
In a democracy, no one should be favored or disadvantaged because of their political beliefs. I am not asking for special treatment. I expect the same standards of the rule of law to which every citizen is entitled.
These include an impartial examination of the evidence, the opportunity to mount a full defense, and a judicial decision based exclusively on the facts and the law in force.
My Faith in the Rule of Law
Despite all the personal and political strain, I remain committed to the principle of the rule of law. Yet, as I have experienced myself, institutions everywhere are staffed by fallible people, some of whom pursue their own interests. Some are absolutely honest, some act carelessly, others are corrupt, and still others act solely to advance their careers.
My statement of 6 February 2024 records how I assessed the allegations against me and the public debate at that time.
A state governed by the rule of law proves its strength not by how vigorously it brings charges, but by how fairly it treats the people it investigates.
Axel E. Fischer · Member of the German Bundestag from 1998 to 2021
Editorial note: This article reflects Axel E. Fischer’s personal perspective as of February 2024. It makes no statement about the subsequent outcome of the proceedings.