Fischer Reaffirms His Statement!
A criminal conviction in Germany does not automatically mean that a person is guilty. Unfortunately, miscarriages of justice have occurred not only in Munich courts!
In January 2026, the Higher Regional Court of Munich delivered a judgment against me. Immediately after the verdict, I described it as a “scandalous judgment from Munich”. I maintain that being convicted in Germany does not automatically mean that one is guilty.
“Judges, too, can make mistakes.” Axel Fischer, January 2026
My case demonstrates in dramatic fashion how the justice system can deliver a judgment based on assumptions and misconceptions that is simply incompatible with the actual facts.
The facts speak for themselves:
The offence of bribery of members of parliament under Section 108e of the German Criminal Code requires an unlawful agreement, action “on behalf of or on the instructions of” another person, and an unjustified advantage. So what are the facts?
- No unlawful agreement: The Munich Public Prosecutor General's Office has never been able to substantiate its allegation of an unlawful agreement. Since I never entered into such an agreement, whether with representatives of Azerbaijan or with any third parties, it will not be able to do so. Nor have I ever acted on anyone else's instructions or behalf. My votes, speeches and other actions were undertaken freely, out of personal conviction.
- No advantage received: The flow of money in January 2016 presumed by the Higher Regional Court of Munich never took place. Nor were there any other unjustified advantages.
- A publicly verifiable speech: The assertion that I delivered an accommodating, improperly favourable speech on behalf of Azerbaijan can readily be refuted. My parliamentary contribution to the debate is freely available online for anyone to read and examine. An objective analysis immediately shows that it was an ordinary, nuanced speech delivered in the exercise of my parliamentary mandate.
The fact that the court in Munich nevertheless reached a conviction shows, in my view, that the judges fell into a serious logical fallacy (circular reasoning) and placed mere conjecture above conclusive evidence.
Miscarriages of justice are not isolated incidents: a look at Munich
Unfortunately, I am not an isolated case. In Munich, in particular, serious miscarriages of justice and judicial errors have come to light—some of which were only uncovered years later. This demonstrates once again that judges are not infallible and that a judicial conviction must never automatically be equated with objective truth.
My central demand: a complete record of criminal court proceedings
To make miscarriages of justice like these less likely in future and to enable those affected to obtain a fair and transparent review, I demand the following:
It is unacceptable that German criminal procedure does not require every spoken word in court to be recorded verbatim. When witness testimony, defence submissions and questions or remarks from judges are not recorded in full, appellate courts and the public are often left in the dark about how flawed decisions arose in the first place. A complete record would also allow the trial court itself to reread or listen to what was actually said. Selective perception could more easily be identified and demonstrated.
Only mandatory audio or video recording, together with verbatim transcripts of the trial, can create genuine transparency, protect innocent people as far as possible against wrongful convictions and strengthen confidence in the rule of law. I remain committed to establishing my innocence in full and to a comprehensive examination of the events in accordance with the rule of law.
Links:- Axel Fischer in an interview with Claudia Jarworski.
- Trial observers report immediately after the court hearing.
- Armenpress reported on January 26, 2016: PACE MPs believe Nagorno Karabakh conflict settlement should remain on Minsk Group agenda.
- Axel Fischers letter to CDU Members of 6 February 2024.